Home, Made Easier

Disclosure: Home, Made Easier may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. Learn more.

An air fryer toaster oven can replace several countertop appliances, but only if it fits your kitchen and the way you actually cook. We compared current models by capacity, functions, cleanup, controls, footprint, and everyday usefulness.

Research note: These recommendations are based on current manufacturer specifications, manuals, warranty information, and documented features. We have not personally hands-on tested every model in this guide, and we do not claim otherwise.

Our top air fryer toaster oven picks

Pick	Best for	Why it stands out	Main tradeoff
Ninja Prestige Smart XL	Most busy households	Extra-large capacity and 10 useful cooking modes	Large countertop footprint
Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro	Frequent cooks	13 modes and unusually broad oven-style versatility	Premium price
Instant Pot Omni Plus 18L	Families wanting value	10 modes, rotisserie, and dishwasher-safe accessories	More accessories to store
Ninja Flip SP151	Small counters	Flips upright when not in use	Shallower oven-style chamber
Cuisinart TOA-70	Simple operation	Roomy capacity with familiar dial controls	Less precise than a digital interface

1. Ninja Prestige Smart XL: Best overall

The Ninja Prestige Smart XL Air Fryer & Countertop Oven is the strongest fit for households that want one machine to handle weeknight meals, toast, pizza, reheating, and larger batches.

Ninja lists 10 cooking functions: Air Fry, Whole Roast, Air Roast, Bake, Dehydrate, Pizza, Broil, Toast, Bagel, and Reheat. That selection covers the modes most people will use without padding the control panel with novelty settings. Its listed dimensions—about 20.04 by 17.09 by 13.35 inches—also make the buying decision clear: this is a substantial appliance that needs permanent counter space.

Why we picked it

• Large capacity suits families and batch cooking.
• The mode list balances air-fryer speed with real countertop-oven flexibility.
• Dedicated toast, bagel, pizza, and reheat settings make it useful beyond dinner.

What to know first

The footprint is the price of the capacity, and Ninja lists the unit as not dishwasher safe. Buyers short on workspace—or anyone who dislikes cleaning racks and trays by hand—should consider a smaller model.

Best for: Families, meal preppers, and anyone who wants a countertop oven to do meaningful work every day.

Check Ninja Prestige Smart XL price on Amazon

2. Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro: Best premium choice

The Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro BOV900 is the most oven-like option here. Breville gives it 13 functions: Toast, Bagel, Broil, Bake, Roast, Warm, Pizza, Proof, Air Fry, Reheat, Cookies, Slow Cook, and Dehydrate.

It can toast up to nine slices and accommodate a 13-inch pizza, making it a realistic secondary oven for households that cook frequently. Proof and slow-cook modes are especially useful for people who want more than fast frozen-food crisping.

Why we picked it

• Broadest cooking range in this group.
• Large interior works for baking, roasting, and entertaining.
• LCD controls are easier to repeat accurately than basic mechanical dials.

What to know first

You pay for the extra capability, and the Breville is physically large. If you mainly cook fries, nuggets, and smaller portions, a less expensive basket air fryer or the Cuisinart below may be the smarter purchase.

Best for: Frequent cooks who will use it as a compact second oven—not just an occasional air fryer.

Check Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro price on Amazon

3. Instant Pot Omni Plus 18L: Best value for families

The Instant Pot Omni Plus 18L packs in 10 cooking functions and a rotisserie setup while remaining easier to justify than many premium ovens.

Instant Pot says it fits six slices of bread or a 12-inch pizza, runs from 170°F to 450°F, and uses 1,800 watts. The listed exterior dimensions are approximately 15.75 inches long, 16.54 inches wide, and 13.9 inches high. The enamel tray, air-frying basket, and accessories are listed as dishwasher safe, a meaningful advantage for a machine likely to see greasy food.

Why we picked it

• Useful 18-liter capacity without the widest footprint in the group.
• Rotisserie adds a genuine capability rather than another preset label.
• Dishwasher-safe accessories reduce routine cleanup.
• One-year limited warranty is clearly documented.

What to know first

The rotisserie accessories need storage, and extra modes only provide value if you use them. Buyers who prefer a few physical dials may find its digital controls busier than the Cuisinart.

Best for: Families wanting a versatile countertop oven with easier accessory cleanup.

Check Instant Pot Omni Plus 18L price on Amazon

4. Ninja Flip SP151: Best for small kitchens

The Ninja Flip Toaster Oven & Air Fryer SP151 solves the biggest countertop-oven problem differently: it flips upright when you are finished, reclaiming work space in front of it.

Ninja lists dimensions of roughly 19.13 by 10.2 by 18.43 inches. The shape is wide, but the flip-up storage design can make more practical sense in a small apartment or first home than a deeper oven that never moves.

Why we picked it

• Flip-away design gives counter space back between uses.
• Wide cooking surface works well for toast, flat foods, and sheet-pan-style portions.
• Strong option when storage matters as much as raw capacity.

What to know first

The shallow format is not the best choice for tall cookware or large roasts. Measure vertical clearance where it will rest in the flipped position, including any upper cabinets.

Best for: Apartments, smaller kitchens, and cooks who cannot dedicate a deep section of counter to an appliance.

Check Ninja Flip SP151 price on Amazon

5. Cuisinart TOA-70: Best simple controls

The Cuisinart TOA-70 Air Fryer Toaster Oven with Grill uses familiar dials and offers eight functions, including air frying, baking, broiling, grilling, and toasting.

Cuisinart says the interior can air fry up to three pounds of wings, toast six bagel halves, bake a three-pound chicken, or fit a 12-inch pizza. That is substantial real-world capacity for a relatively straightforward appliance.

Why we picked it

• Physical controls are fast to understand and easy to share with guests or family.
• Grill function adds versatility without a complex interface.
• Capacity handles common family foods and a standard 12-inch pizza.

What to know first

Analog dials are simple, but they are not as precise or repeatable as a clear digital display. If exact time and temperature adjustments matter to you, choose the Ninja Prestige, Breville, or Instant model.

Best for: Buyers who value familiar controls and useful capacity over smart features.

Check Cuisinart TOA-70 price on Amazon

How to choose the right model

Measure more than the appliance

Check width, depth, height, door clearance, and the ventilation space required by the manual. A machine that technically fits may still block a cabinet door or consume the prep space you use every night.

Choose for your most common meal

A 12-inch pizza rating is useful if pizza is actually part of the routine. A wide basket matters for wings and vegetables. A tall cavity matters more for roasting. Buy around the food you make weekly, not the longest feature list.

Do not underestimate cleanup

Air frying moves grease and crumbs around a hot chamber. Removable crumb trays, accessible interiors, and dishwasher-safe accessories can matter more after six months than one additional preset.

Decide between simple and repeatable controls

Dials are quick and familiar. Digital controls make it easier to repeat an exact program. Neither is automatically better; the best interface is the one everyone in the household will use confidently.

Confirm the electrical setup

Many full-size countertop ovens draw around 1,800 watts. Follow the manufacturer’s placement and electrical instructions, avoid crowding the vents, and do not assume an extension cord is appropriate.

Air fryer toaster oven vs. basket air fryer

Choose an oven-style model when you want toast, pizza, baking, or a wider cooking surface. Choose a basket air fryer when your priority is fast crisping, simpler shaking, and a smaller footprint. A basket model is often easier for one or two people; an oven model is usually more flexible for a household replacing a toaster oven.

Frequently asked questions

Can an air fryer toaster oven replace a toaster?

For most households, yes. Dedicated toast settings and multi-slice capacity make these models practical toaster replacements, although browning can vary with rack position and bread type.

Can it replace a full-size oven?

It can handle many everyday meals with less space to preheat, but capacity remains the limit. Large cookware, multiple trays, holiday meals, and tall roasts may still require a full-size oven.

Is the most expensive model automatically best?

No. The Breville earns its place through versatility, but that only matters if you use proofing, slow cooking, dehydrating, or larger oven-style tasks. The simpler Cuisinart may be the better value for straightforward air frying and toasting.

Which one is easiest to fit in a small kitchen?

The Ninja Flip is the most space-conscious design when stored upright. Still, measure both its operating position and its flipped height before buying.

Our recommendation

For most busy households with enough counter space, the Ninja Prestige Smart XL offers the best balance of capacity and useful everyday modes. Choose the Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro when you want a true countertop second oven, the Instant Pot Omni Plus when cleanup and family value matter most, the Ninja Flip when counter space is tight, or the Cuisinart TOA-70 when simple controls are the priority.

Before buying, measure your space and read the current manufacturer manual. The right model is the one that makes the meals you already cook easier—not the one with the most impressive box.

---

Next: Visit our Kitchen & Cleaning guide hub, or learn how Home, Made Easier evaluates products.